UNCERTAINTY > Origins
The
uncertainty relations express a structural constraint that applies to the statistical results of measurements involving
incompatible observables. To see what it means for two observables to be incompatible, let us first consider two observables
A and
B separately.
A system can always be prepared (at least in principle) in such a way
that by repeating several times the sequence ‘preparation
P + measurement of
A’, one always gets the same value
ai. (One says in this case that, given the preparation
P, the
probability of finding
ai if
A is measured is 1.) Analogously, one can prepare a system in such a way that the
probability of getting
bi in a measurement of
B is 1. However, if the two observables are
incompatible, it is impossible to find a preparation procedure such that a
joint measurement of
A and
B will yield
ai and
bi with
probability 1. In other words, the measurements of
A and
B look as if they were not independent (as if they ‘interfered’ with each other).
This fact is linked to the geometrical relation existing between the structures that represent
incompatible observables in the
state space. A simple illustration is provided by the case of two
spin components Sz and
Sx. Consider the toy model discussed in the section on the
superposition principle. It is clear that
no state vector assigns
probability 1 to one of the following results:

&

,

&

,

&

,

&

. (This is because the axis representing
Sx and the axis representing
Sz in the
state space are neither parallel nor orthogonal.)
By generalizing this kind of argument to the formalism of
Hilbert spaces, one can prove that, since position and momentum are
incompatible observables with a
continuous spectrum of outcomes, they must obey
inequality (1).
Owing to their deep connection with
complementarity, the
Heisenberg relations are linked to the wavelike behaviour of quantum systems. In fact, it is a well-known theorem from Fourier analysis that the spectral width Δk of a signal is inversely proportional to its spatial extension Δx. If, following
Louis de Broglie, we associate a
wave packet of spectral width Δk = hΔp/2π with a particle, the Fourier relation for the
wave packet reads exactly as
(1).